Pocket Watches: Railroad Standards, Repeaters and Automata
The Japonista Curation and Concierge Team
On an April evening in 1891, at the small station of Kipton in Ohio, a fast mail train and a slower passenger train met head-on, on the same line, at the same moment. Nine men died, six of them postal clerks on the fast mail. The Smithsonian's National Postal Museum records that the investigation centred on the engineers' watches, one of which was possibly four minutes slow.
Those four minutes did more than any other event to shape the American pocket watch. Over the next three decades they produced a standard, an inspection system, and movements made to a precision no ordinary customer needed. The same discipline reached Japan, which ran its trains on imported railway watches for nearly sixty years before a Tokyo factory made one good enough to replace them. The story belongs beside Ginza and the watch, where that Tokyo factory's founder kept his shop.
Railroad standards are only one branch of the pocket watch. Beside them grew the repeater, which strikes the time on gongs, and the automaton, which makes small figures move. All three are in the house today, and each asks different questions of a collector.
Four minutes at Kipton
After the collision, the Lake Shore and Michigan Southern Railway called in Webb C. Ball, a Cleveland jeweller. When the railroads adopted Standard Time in 1883, he became the first jeweller to bring time signals to Cleveland. According to the National Postal Museum, his investigation led to watch performance and inspection standards in 1893. The Encyclopedia of Cleveland History records that his inspection service grew to cover three quarters of the country's railroads, run from his jewellery business in Cleveland.
The accounts do not agree on the details. The Postal Museum gives 18 April. The Ball company history gives 19 April and describes an engineer's watch that stopped for four minutes and then ran on. The Cleveland encyclopedia counts 13 dead; the Ball history names both engineers and nine clerks. Members of the National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors have noted that no document from before about 1910 blames the wreck on a watch at all. What nobody disputes is the system Ball built: watches checked by an approved watchmaker at regular intervals, with the rates written down.
What a railroad watch had to be
There was never one universal rule. Each railroad appointed time inspectors, and the requirements rose as the factories improved. A typical list from the early twentieth century reads like a specification sheet:
| Requirement | Typical rule | Why it mattered |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 16 or 18 size | A large, robust movement |
| Jewels | at least 17 after 1895 (15 before) | Less wear at the pivots |
| Rate | within 30 seconds a week | About four seconds a day, checked at inspection |
| Adjustment | five positions, temperature and isochronism | Steady in a pocket, on a table, in heat and cold |
| Case and dial | open face, stem at 12; Arabic numerals after 1906 | Read at a glance |
| Setting | lever set after 1908 | No accidental change of time while winding |
The lever-set rule is the one a collector meets first. On a true railroad watch the crown only winds. To set the hands you open the bezel and pull out a small lever at the edge of the dial. If a watch sets from the crown, it was not made to this standard, whatever its dial says.
Springfield and the Bunn Special
The Illinois Watch Company was founded in Springfield in 1870. Its most famous grade carries the name of John W. Bunn, one of the founding directors. According to the collectors' association encyclopedia, the Bunn Special arrived as an 18-size, 21-jewel railroad grade in 1895–96, and a 16-size version followed in 1913. In 1926 Illinois announced that the Bunn Special would now run for 60 hours, at a time when most railroad watches ran for about 42. A railwayman who forgot to wind his watch after a double shift still had the right time.
The factory changed hands soon after. The Hamilton Watch Company agreed to buy Illinois in December 1927 and took control on 1 January 1928. Collectors use the dial to tell the two periods apart: Hamilton-era Bunn Specials moved from the "arrows in" five-minute markers to "arrows out". An Illinois Bunn Special 23-jewel, 60-hour in the house carries a private-label railroad dial and a 14K white gold-filled case with a display back.
Howard, the Keystone years
E. Howard of Boston was one of the oldest names in American watchmaking. In 1902 the Keystone Watch Case Company bought the right to use the name, and the watches of the following decades are known to collectors as Keystone Howards. The Series 10 was a 16-size, 21-jewel, open-face, lever-set railroad watch, and it appears in a catalogue by 1912.
A Howard Series 10 of about 1913 shows the full railroad grammar: a porcelain enamel dial with bold Arabic numerals, blued steel hands, a sub-seconds register, and an Extra-Adjusted movement in a 51.3 mm 14K gold-filled Keystone case. Gold-filled means a thick layer of gold bonded to a base metal. It is not solid gold, and on an old case the wear shows first at the bow and the edges.
Japan: sixty years of imported time
Japan's first railway opened between Shimbashi and Yokohama on 14 October 1872. A year later, as our piece on wadokei and Edo seasonal time explains, the country left its variable hours behind for the Western clock. Trains made the change practical, and they needed watches that Japan did not yet make.
The National Museum of Nature and Science keeps a record of what followed. From the early Meiji years until 1929, the railways used watches from Europe and America. In November 1929 the Minister of Railways designated a 19-ligne pocket watch from Seikosha, the Tokyo factory of Kintaro Hattori, as the first Japanese-made railway watch. The museum entry calls it a landmark for the industry: the strictest standard in watchmaking, written after American railway accidents, had now been met by a Japanese watch. Telephone exchanges also used the watch to time calls.
Seikosha had made its first pocket watch, the Timekeeper, in 1895, three years after the company was founded. The Seiko Museum Ginza keeps both in its collection. Collectors' references record that the 19-ligne watch had seven jewels and was made, with changes, until 1971. Seikosha's later story runs through to the Seiko Astron, the quartz wristwatch that opened a new age of timekeeping in 1969.
Geneva, Saint-Imier and Fifth Avenue
The American factories were not the only makers of railway watches. Railroads approved certain Swiss watches where spare parts were available, and Swiss open-face watches made in the same style were sold across the world. Longines dates its beginning to 1832, when Auguste Agassiz and fellow watchmakers set up a workshop in the Swiss village of Saint-Imier. Its winged hourglass, first registered in Switzerland in 1889, is the oldest valid trademark in WIPO's international register, and it has never been modified.
Longines also made watches for retailers who put their own name on the dial. A sterling silver watch of 1911 is signed "Made for Tiffany & Co." and "By the Longines Watch Co.", with matching case and movement numbers. New York's jeweller marked its silver with the same care, as Tiffany silver hallmarks shows. The watch is on the Longines shelf, beside an open-face Longines of 1908 with a Roman enamel dial; the Tiffany shelf holds the maker's other watches.
Repeaters: time you can hear
Before electric light, a watch that struck the time on demand was a real convenience. In 1687 the London makers Edward Barlow and Daniel Quare both sought a patent for repeating watches. The Victoria and Albert Museum records that King James II's council preferred Quare's version, which struck the hours and quarters at a single push. The Fondation Haute Horlogerie shares the credit between Barlow, Quare and Thomas Tompion. The minute repeater, which strikes the hours, quarters and minutes, came later. The same foundation places the first examples in southern Germany around 1700–1710, although Thomas Mudge has traditionally been credited with it, around 1750. On a pocket watch, a slide on the case band sets the strike going.
Repeaters were often combined with other complications. A Donne & Son grand complication made in London in the nineteenth century joins a minute repeater, a perpetual calendar and a moonphase in an 18K gold hunter case. A hunter case has a hinged lid that closes over the dial. Another watch in the house, dated 1864 and cased in 14K gold, pairs a minute repeater with a painted enamel dial and an automaton figure that moves while it strikes.
Automata: the watch as a small stage
Sainte-Croix, in the Vaud Jura, became the Swiss centre for mechanical music. Charles Reuge opened his workshop there in 1865, making and repairing musical pocket watches, and the company he founded later became known for music boxes. The Reuge pocket watches in the house have raised, painted scenes on the dial side, horsemen, columns and trees around a fountain, in gold-plated cases of 57 and 58 mm. Both run as watches. On both, the automaton or the music no longer plays, and we say so plainly on each page.
That honesty matters for this kind of watch. An automaton has a second mechanism, sometimes more delicate than the movement, and it is common for one to work and the other not. Ask which functions run, and whether a repair has been tried.
What to check before you buy
- Movement and case belong together. Matching serial numbers, or a case signed for the same maker and the period, mean a marriage is less likely. Many American movements were sold uncased and cased by the jeweller, so a period case from another maker can still be original to the watch.
- Read the movement, not the dial. The grade name, jewel count and adjustment are engraved on the plates. A "railroad" dial on a pendant-set movement is decoration.
- Porcelain dials crack. Look for hairlines around the winding arbor and the seconds register in raking light. Chips at the edge can hide under the bezel.
- Gold-filled is not solid gold. Look for the stamp inside the back, and for wear to brass at the bow, the pendant and the hinge.
- Ask what runs. For a repeater, ask whether every strike sounds. For an automaton, ask whether the figure moves. On a hundred-year-old watch, timekeeping of a few minutes a day is normal.
- Box, paper and key add to the story. The box, papers and the full set matter for a pocket watch too, and the key is often missing from a key-wound watch.
Storage is simple. Keep the watch in a box away from damp, wind it at the same time each day if you carry it, and keep the bow and crystal from knocking against keys. In Japan, keeping a fine watch in its box is a long habit; kept in the box tells that wider story. For the houses and their family trees, the Watch Almanac sets each maker in its place.
Questions collectors ask
Was every railroad watch American?
No. American railroads approved certain Swiss watches where spare parts were available. Japan used European and American watches until the Seikosha railway watch was designated in 1929.
What does "adjusted to five positions" mean?
The watchmaker regulated the watch dial up, dial down and with the crown pointing up, left and right, so it kept the same rate on a table or in a pocket. Illinois advertised its Bunn and Sangamo Specials as adjusted to six.
Is a pocket watch practical to carry today?
A serviced railroad grade will keep good time for daily use. Wind it every day at the same hour, and have it serviced by a watchmaker who works on antique movements.
Why do so many automaton watches no longer move?
The automaton is a separate train of wheels and levers, often more fragile than the watch itself. Parts may be missing or worn, and few workshops repair them.
Looking for a particular railroad grade, a repeater or an automaton? Tell us the maker, the grade and the condition you have in mind.
References
- Smithsonian National Postal Museum, The Great Kipton Train Wreck
- Encyclopedia of Cleveland History, Ball, Webb C.
- Ball Watch, company history
- NAWCC forums, the 1891 Kipton wreck and Webb C. Ball
- Railroad chronometer, typical requirements
- NAWCC encyclopedia, Illinois Watch Company
- Pocket Watch Database, Bunn Special dials, July 2021
- Pocket Watch Database, E. Howard Watch Co. (Keystone)
- Longines, history of the house
- WIPO Magazine, Longines Watch Company: Madrid's oldest mark
- Reuge, our story
- V&A, repeating watch by Daniel Quare
- Fondation Haute Horlogerie, Repeater
- National Archives of Japan, the Shimbashi to Yokohama railway
- National Museum of Nature and Science, Seikosha 19-ligne railway watch record
- Seiko Museum Ginza, history of Seiko, stage 1
- Watch Wiki, Seiko Type 19
Further reading
- Ginza and the watch, for the street where Kintaro Hattori kept his shop
- Wadokei, for the hours Japan kept before the railway watch
- The Watch Almanac, for the houses behind the names on the dials
- The grading guide, for how we describe condition on an antique watch
- Hamilton watches, for the Lancaster house of the railroad 992B
- Marine chronometers became a wristwatch house: Ulysse Nardin, from the Marine to the Freak.
- Ball watches: the railroad standard, the Engineer and the Hydrocarbon, for Webb C. Ball's timekeeping rules and the micro gas lights of the Swiss revival
- Waltham watches: the Vanguard, the A-11 and the Maxim, for the American system of interchangeable parts and the railroad grades
- The collectible watches shelf, for the pocket watches in the house today