Japanese Camera Myths and Fakes | Japonista
Almanac · The Doubtful Page
Japanese Camera Myths and Fakes
カメラの俗説
Camera history is told by makers, dealers and enthusiasts, and each has reasons to tell it with a flourish. This chapter takes ten familiar claims about Japanese cameras and sorts them into what the evidence supports, what is disputed, and what we could not verify. Where we could not decide, we say so.
Fact sheet
At a glance
- Disputed. The first microprocessor camera, and the dates of several landmarks.
- Narrowed. The first autofocus SLR: only a narrow wording survives.
- Unverified. Sales figures that circulate without a source.
- Advice. A repainted body is not always a fake, but it must be described as repainted.
Why a Collector Needs a Doubtful Page
A myth in camera history is not a lie. It is a sentence that has been repeated until nobody remembers who first said it, and it nearly always contains something true. The first Japanese cameras did study a German original. The Korean War did introduce Nikkor lenses to photographers who then wrote about them. The Contax T2 does cost a great deal more than it did. The myth is the small additional claim that rides on the truth: that the copy was a mere copy, that the war made the reputation, that the price is a sign of quality.
The thesis of this chapter is that a myth is a price. Each claim that circulates about a camera raises or lowers what someone will pay for it, and a buyer who cannot tell a documented claim from a repeated one will pay for the repetition. The remedy is not scepticism of the cynical kind, which refuses to believe anything, but a habit of sorting: what a source states plainly, what two sources dispute, what is merely said. That is the ledger of this chapter, now enlarged with the claims that surround the cameras of the other chapters.
We cite the Wikipedia article or the trade report for each claim, we say where an article carries a flag such as “citation needed”, and we say where two parts of the same article disagree. Nothing here is a valuation, and no verdict is advice to buy.
How We Sort a Claim
Each claim below has one of four verdicts. Supported means that a source we could read states it plainly. Disputed means that two reputable sources disagree, and we give both. Unverified means that we found the claim repeated but not sourced, and we do not repeat it as fact. Advice means that the matter is practical rather than historical.
The principal source is Wikipedia, whose camera articles are uneven; where we lean on a hobby website, we say so. Nothing in this chapter is a valuation, and no claim here should be taken as a reason to buy or to refuse a camera.
Five Stories Behind the Claims
The first through-the-lens meter. The Pentax Spotmatic, launched in 1964 after a prototype at photokina in 1960, is often called the first SLR with through-the-lens metering. Wikipedia’s own article on the camera is more careful, calling it one of the first, and does not mention the Topcon RE Super of 1963. The Topcon article says that several common features of 35 mm SLR photography were first seen on the RE Super, among them through-the-lens metering, but the sentence carries no citation, and the claim that the launch took the entire industry by surprise is also unsourced. The Topcon article adds that the maker’s first 35 mm SLR, the Topcon R of 1957, came about two years before the Nikon F and the Canonflex. The honest statement is that the question of who was first is open between at least two Japanese makers, and that the Spotmatic’s fame rests on its success more than on its priority.

A Nikon F on display at the Nikon Museum in Shinagawa, Tokyo.
K6ka, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
The metering that was not full-aperture. The same article makes a second point that the legend omits. The original Spotmatic metered stop-down: a lever on the side stopped the lens down and switched the meter on, which limited low-light performance. The Topcon RE Super, by contrast, metered at full aperture through a mirror cut with narrow slits that let a fraction of the light reach a CdS cell behind it, and the lenses carried an aperture simulator. Only with the Spotmatic F of 1973, and the supercoated Takumars with their aperture-coupling prong, did the Pentax meter at open aperture. A claim about being first is therefore also a claim about which kind of first.
The invention of the half-frame. The Olympus Pen of 1959 is the camera most often credited with making the 18 by 24 mm half-frame format popular, and the Wikipedia article on half-frame cameras confirms that the format became popular as a cheaper alternative in the 1960s, especially in Japan, with the Pen models among the most popular. It also traces the frame to Edison’s motion-picture frame, and lists earlier or parallel limited-run half-frame cameras, among them the Leica 72 of 1950, made in Canada, and the Nikon S3M of 1960 to 1961. The Pen did not invent the format. It did make it ordinary, which is the achievement that the Olympus chapter claims for Maitani, and the one the Pentax 17 of 2024 now draws on with its roughly 72 shots per roll.
The camera named in German. Wikipedia reports that Carl Zeiss objected in the early 1950s that the name Nikon sounded too like its own Ikon brand, and that from 1963 to 1968 the F was labelled Nikkor in Germany. The cameras are now collectors’ items. This is among the best-documented curiosities in the book and it is also a warning: an engraving that looks like an error may be a clue.
The celebrity and the price. A Digital Camera World writer reports that the Contax T2, which cost a couple of hundred dollars not long ago, rose to nearly $2,500 after a celebrity began using it. We repeat the report and name nobody, since the article does not support a name, and we add that no single cause has been proved for a rise in any price. What can be said is that prices for older compacts have moved far beyond the cost of repair, and that Wikipedia’s article on point-and-shoot cameras reports renewed, nostalgia-driven interest in older compacts from 2023.
Twelve More Claims, Weighed
The first chapter ledger above covers the ten claims with which this chapter began. The table below adds twelve more, drawn from the research done since. The verdict words are the same: supported, disputed, unverified or advice.

User Smial on de.wikipedia, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Canon AE-1 camera in black
Gameplay010unused, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
| Claim | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| The Pentax Spotmatic was the first through-the-lens SLR | Qualified | Wikipedia calls it one of the first; the Topcon RE Super of 1963 is reported to have preceded it, but the sentence is unsourced. |
| Topcon’s first 35 mm SLR preceded the Nikon F by two years | Reported | The Topcon R of 1957 is stated in the RE Super article; we have not checked the Nikon dates against another source. |
| The Olympus Pen invented the half-frame | Not supported | Edison’s film frame, the Leica 72 of 1950 and the Nikon S3M show earlier half-frame stills. The Pen made the format popular. |
| A half-frame camera gives 72 shots on a 36-exposure roll | Supported | The half-frame article gives the figure, and the Pentax 17 is reported to give about 72. |
| The Nikon F was sold as the Nikkor F in Germany | Supported | Wikipedia dates it to 1963 to 1968, after an objection by Zeiss. |
| The Electro Spotmatic was the first aperture-priority electronic SLR | Unverified | Attributed to a source in Wikipedia but not verified further. |
| The Yashica Electro 35 was the first commercially successful electronic 35 mm camera | Reported | Wikipedia states it, with about eight million sold; its dates differ by one year between pages. |
| The Pentax 17 is Pentax’s first film camera in over two decades | Supported | Wikipedia and Wallpaper* agree. |
| Film prices have roughly doubled since 2018 | Reported | A trade writer reports a five-pack of Portra 400 at about $54 in 2018 and about $109 when in stock. |
| Leica film-camera sales rose 900 per cent in eight years | Unverified | The trade report gives the figure without substantiation. |
| A celebrity raised the price of the Contax T2 to nearly $2,500 | Reported | A trade report, with no name; price rises have more than one cause. |
| Film photography is dying | Unsettled | Pentax launched a film camera in 2024 and Kodak hired people, while prices rise and some stocks have been discontinued. |
Three Questions for Any Claim
The questions we used on the claims above are simple, and a buyer can use them without any special knowledge.
Who says so? A maker’s museum or a standard reference is better than a forum, and a forum is better than a rumour. Canon’s own camera museum is the source for the Leica study that began its first camera; Wikipedia, with all its unevenness, gives a trail of citations that a reader can follow; a hobby website is useful for tips, less so for dates. The Nikkor-F-in-Germany claim is a good example of a statement that reads like a rumour and is in fact documented.
What exactly is claimed? “First” is the most slippery word in camera history. First to be announced, to be sold, to be mass-produced, to be successful? First anywhere or first in Japan? First with a feature at full aperture, or with the feature at all? The Maxxum 7000 is a good case: earlier autofocus SLRs exist, and only a narrower wording survives. The Konica C35 AF is described as the first mass-produced autofocus camera, which is a narrower claim again.
Who gains? The advertisement, the dealer’s description and the price tag all favour a larger story. That does not make them false. It means that a claim which raises the price should be held to a higher standard than one which lowers it.
How a Myth Becomes a Premium
The route from sentence to price is short. A claim, true or not, is repeated in a description; the description is copied; the copy is found by a buyer who has seen the claim three times and takes it as established. The trade writer who reports that the Contax T2 rose in price after a celebrity used it describes the same mechanism from the other end: demand moves first, and the explanation follows.

CONTAX T2 titanium body autofocus camera
User:Gisling, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
There is no cure for this, but there is a defence. A buyer who has read the sources can discount the premium for the story and pay for what is actually there: the condition of the body, the state of the lens, the completeness of the outfit. Our bench guide supplies the tests; this chapter supplies the stories that the tests do not need.

The classic.
E Magnuson, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
The house’s own approach is to describe each camera as it is, to mark what has been tested and what has not, and to leave the legend to the history pages. A description that is long on legend and short on condition is a sign to ask more questions.
Does It Fit? Myths of the Mount
The commonest practical myth is that a lens which fits a body will work on it. The sources show how often the opposite is true. Wikipedia’s article on the Nikon SP says that Contax lenses fit the Nikon rangefinder physically but do not focus accurately on it, which is why the two systems are described as related but not interchangeable. The rangefinder article reports that Canon’s cameras from 1946 were roughly compatible with the Leica thread mount, and from late 1951 fully so, a distinction that matters to anyone mounting a screw-fit lens on a Canon of the early years.

Alex van Essen, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
The same caution runs through the reflex mounts. The Minolta A mount made the firm’s older lenses obsolete in 1985, and Canon’s EF mount abandoned the FD system in 1987. Nikon’s F and Pentax’s K bayonets, in the words of the SLR article, were the only two SLR mounts not abandoned. A lens that fits in the sense that it can be adapted may lose a function, its autofocus, its aperture coupling or its infinity focus, and the lens chapter explains which mounts allow which adaptations.

Photo showing the Nikon S-mount on the Nikon SP camera. This lens mount was used in the Nikon interchangeable-lens range finder cameras and was a copy of the pr
Sshenoy Sudhir Shenoy, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
The verdict is advice: before buying a lens for a body, ask for the mount by name, ask whether the pairing is native or adapted, and ask what is lost. A description that says only “fits” has not answered the question.
Curiosities from the Doubtful Page
Each of these is drawn from the Wikipedia articles and trade reports cited in this chapter.

Joost J. Bakker from IJmuiden, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
- The Topcon R of 1957 came about two years before the Nikon F and the Canonflex, according to Wikipedia.
- The Spotmatic was shown as a prototype at photokina in 1960 and released in 1964.
- Original Spotmatic metering was designed as spot but became centre-weighted, says Wikipedia, which also notes a discrepancy over the battery type between its infobox and its text.
- The SP500 had a top shutter speed of 1/500, and users found an unmarked stop on its dial at the 1/1000 position.
- A batch of thirty Minolta X-300 cameras was modified as half-frame cameras for the Dutch police, according to the half-frame article.
- The Konica Auto-Reflex is described as a mechanical peak of the half-frame SLR, and the Yashica Samurai as the most advanced electronic half-frame SLR.
- Kodak hired 300 people to increase film output, a trade writer reports.
- The Nikon F wore the name Nikkor F in Germany for five years, from 1963 to 1968.
A Small Doubtful Glossary
Verdict. One of supported, disputed, unverified, advice, qualified, reported or unsettled.
Qualified. A claim true only with a narrower wording.
Reported. A claim stated by a source we have read but not checked against another.
Unsettled. A question on which the evidence points both ways.
Citation needed. The flag Wikipedia attaches to an unsourced statement.
Stop-down metering. Metering with the lens closed to the working aperture.
Full-aperture metering. Metering with the lens at its widest opening, kept bright for the eye.
Half-frame. A format of 18 by 24 mm, doubling the shots on a roll.
Ten Claims, Weighed
The table gives the claim, the verdict and the reasoning in brief. The sections that follow expand the four that matter most.
Pablo M Coronel, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Olympus Pen F w/zuiko 38mm f/1.8
Hiyotada, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
| Claim | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| The first Japanese cameras were Leica copies | Partly supported | Canon’s own museum says its founder studied a Leica; Wikipedia calls the Kwanon prototype a copy of the Leica design. The Nikon I of 1948 combined features of the Contax and the Leica. “Copy” is a simplification. |
| The Canon AE-1 was the first microprocessor camera | Disputed | Two differently worded claims and one 1977 source; see the Canon chapter. |
| The Minolta Maxxum 7000 was the first autofocus SLR | Narrowed | Earlier autofocus SLRs exist, among them the Nikon F3AF of 1983 and the Pentax ME F; only a narrower claim about integrated autofocus with motorised film advance survives. |
| The Konica C35 AF was the first mass-produced autofocus camera | Reported | Wikipedia states it with three citations we have not examined. |
| The Nikon F4 was the first professional autofocus SLR | Company claim | Attributed to the company in the Nikon chapter. |
| The Contax T2 was made in Germany | Not supported | Kyocera made the camera and Yashica made the lens in partnership with Carl Zeiss; see the Contax chapter. |
| The Contax T2 was introduced in 1990 | Disputed | Sources give 1990 or 1991. |
| The Minolta and Konica merger was in 2003 | Disputed | Sources give 2003 or 2004. |
| Five million Olympus Trip 35s were sold | Unverified | Estimates of 5 million and 7.5 million appear without citations, and Wikipedia’s article on the camera says over ten million. We give no figure. |
| Takumar lenses are dangerous | Advice | Hobby writing reports thorium in some Takumars; the risk is described as very low in that source. We make no assessment and refer readers to a radiation-safety authority. |
“Just a Leica Copy”
The story that Japan’s first cameras were Leica copies has a basis, and a limit. Canon’s own museum says that Gorō Yoshida took a Leica Model II apart to study it, and Wikipedia describes the 1934 Kwanon prototype as a copy of the Leica design. Canon also fitted a Nikkor lens to its first production camera, the Hansa Canon of 1936. That is the evidence for copying.

s58y, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
The limit is that copying is a way into a craft, not a description of where it ended. The Nikon I of 1948 joined the Contax bayonet shape to Leica-style focusing, and by the 1950s the reflex designs of Asahi, Nikon and Canon owed little to either. A fair wording is that Japanese makers learned from German designs and then, in the reflex, designed something their teachers did not.

You can see what M-san was going after when he designed the OM-1.
erik gould from Pawtucket RI, United States, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Rama, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Repainted Bodies and Reissues
Collectors pay more for some finishes than for others, and the difference invites fakes. A body repainted black to resemble a rarer finish, a chrome body sold as a limited edition, a serial number that does not match the paperwork: these are the usual cases. The bench guide suggests asking whether the serial number matches the documents and whether the dealer will accept a return. For a first purchase, the photographs, not the adjectives, are the evidence.
Bubba73 (Jud McCranie), CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
There are also honest reissues. Our earlier guide to Japanese rangefinders reports that Nikon issued reproductions of the S3 in 2000 and of the SP in 2005, and we have not checked those dates against another source. A reissue is not a fake, but it must be sold as a reissue, and its price should say so.
Yashica Electro 35 CC Kamera
Denis Barthel, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Counterfeit lens markings and badge swaps are a further case, but we found no source that gives reliable numbers for them, and we make no claim about how common they are.
Cleaning Lenses at Home
A common belief is that lens fungus can be wiped away. Jim Grey’s inspection guide says that fungus can sometimes be cleaned but that any etching of the glass is permanent, and that haze is usually a reason to walk away. A lens cleaned without taking it apart cleans only its outer surfaces. For internal marks, the answer is a technician, not a cloth.

The single lens reflex (SLR) camera Minolta srT 101b was built between 1977 and 1981 as a "general model" of the SR-T serie of Minolta.
Isiwal, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
The same applies to the yellowing of some old lenses. A hobby writer reports that sunlight and ultraviolet lamps are said to reduce the yellow, and also reports a lens harmed by heat. We repeat the report and the caution, not the treatment.
The Korean War Story
The most familiar story of Nikon’s rise is that photographers covering the Korean War, among them David Douglas Duncan, adopted Nikkor lenses and the reputation followed. The outline is confirmed in Wikipedia and in Nikon’s own emphasis on cold-weather durability. The details, including which lenses were used and how many photographers did so, are anecdotal, and we treat the story as an outline.
A related story, that the Nikon F was sold in Germany as the Nikkor F because of the Zeiss name, appears in the Nikon chapter as an uncited claim. We include it as such.
Evidence in pictures

1936 Hansa Canon with Nikkor 50mm f/3.5
Look closer: The lens on the front is a Nikkor, not a Canon: the evidence for the cooperation behind the first Canon camera.
Morio, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Black Canon AE-1 (1976) SLR camera with a 50mm f/1.8 lens
Look closer: The best-selling camera of 1976, and the centre of a priority dispute that sources do not settle.
en:User:Cburnett, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
The Camera Shelf
The house keeps a small shelf of Japanese cameras, and keeps it honest: at the time of writing it holds Contax T2 compacts with Carl Zeiss lenses, each photographed and described with its condition set out. If a body or lens you want is not there, the concierge desk can look for it in Japan.
Answered plainly
Were the first Japanese cameras Leica copies?
Partly. Canon’s founder studied a Leica and the Kwanon prototype is described as a copy of the Leica design, but later designs diverged.
Which camera was the first autofocus SLR?
A narrow claim for the Maxxum 7000 survives; earlier autofocus SLRs exist, so we do not say first without qualification.
Was the Canon AE-1 the first microprocessor camera?
The claim is disputed; see the Canon chapter for both wordings.
Is the Contax T2 German?
No. Kyocera made the camera and Yashica made the lens in partnership with Carl Zeiss.
Is a repainted camera a fake?
Not necessarily, but it must be described as repainted.
Can I clean lens fungus myself?
Surface cleaning, yes; internal fungus needs a technician, and etching is permanent.
Was the Pentax Spotmatic the first through-the-lens SLR?
Wikipedia calls it one of the first. The Topcon RE Super of 1963 is reported to have preceded it, though the sentence is unsourced.
Did the Olympus Pen invent the half-frame camera?
No. Earlier half-frame stills exist, among them the Leica 72 of 1950; the Pen made the format popular.
Why was the Nikon F called the Nikkor F in Germany?
Wikipedia reports that Carl Zeiss objected that Nikon sounded too like Ikon, and that the F was so labelled from 1963 to 1968.
Is the Contax T2 expensive because of a celebrity?
A trade writer reports that its price rose after a celebrity used it; we cannot confirm a single cause.
Is film really twice the price?
A trade writer reports a Portra 400 five-pack at about $54 in 2018 and about $109 when in stock.
Can I trust a camera claim I read online?
Ask who says so, what exactly is claimed and who gains. A claim that raises the price deserves the harder test.
Where next
Sources and image credits
- Canon Inc., Wikipedia
- Nikon, Wikipedia
- Contax T, Wikipedia
- Konica C35 AF, Wikipedia
- Minolta, Wikipedia
- Inspecting vintage film cameras before you buy, part 1 (Jim Grey)
- Canon Camera Museum
- Pentax Spotmatic, Wikipedia
- Topcon RE Super, Wikipedia
- Half-frame camera, Wikipedia
- Yashica Electro 35, Wikipedia
- Point-and-shoot camera, Wikipedia
- Is the price of 35mm film killing the film photography revival? (Digital Camera World)
- New Pentax 17 35mm camera heralds the return of film (Wallpaper*)
- Image: Nikon F at Nikon Museum, K6ka (CC BY-SA 4.0)
- Image: Schlitzverschluss 1 60s, User Smial on de.wikipedia (CC BY-SA 2.0)
- Image: Canon AE-1 in black, Gameplay010unused (CC BY 4.0)
- Image: CONTAX T2, User:Gisling (CC BY-SA 3.0)
- Image: Pentax-K1000, E Magnuson (CC BY 2.0)
- Image: Asahi Pentax Takumar 135mm f2.5 (AvE)01, Alex van Essen (CC BY-SA 4.0)
- Image: Nikon-S-mount, Sshenoy Sudhir Shenoy (CC BY 3.0)
- Image: Olympus Trip 35, Joost J. Bakker from IJmuiden (CC BY 2.0)
- Image: Pentax Spotmatic and lenses, Pablo M Coronel (CC BY-SA 3.0)
- Image: Olympus PenF, Hiyotada (CC BY-SA 3.0)
- Image: Nicca IIIB, s58y (CC BY 2.0)
- Image: OM-1n vs. Leica I, erik gould from Pawtucket RI, United States (CC BY 2.0)
- Image: Leotax img 1855, Rama (CC BY-SA 2.0)
- Image: Asahi Pentax logo, Bubba73 (Jud McCranie) (CC BY-SA 4.0)
- Image: Yashica Electro 35 CC, Denis Barthel (CC BY-SA 4.0)
- Image: Minolta srT101b CLC, Isiwal (CC BY-SA 4.0)
- Image: A Hansa Canon with a Nikkor lens, Morio (CC BY-SA 4.0)
- Image: A Canon AE-1, en:User:Cburnett (CC BY-SA 3.0)
Last reviewed 28 October 2026. Pictures are public-domain or openly licensed and credited beneath each one; diagrams are drawn by Japonista.
Unsure about a camera you have been offered? The concierge desk replies within one to three business days.
Return to the Japanese Camera Almanac · Make a private request
Private concierge
Looking for something in particular?
Describe the piece or the project you have in mind. A senior advisor in Tokyo reads every case file personally and replies within two business days, with fees set out in writing before any work begins.