Character or Fault: Reading the Condition of Japanese Furniture
Japanese Furniture · Condition
An old chest arrives with its life written on it. Some of that writing is the reason to own it; some of it is damage that stops the piece doing its job. This guide shows where Japonista draws the line, with paired examples, so you can read a condition report the way we write one.

What we mean by character
Character is the texture a piece acquires over a long life: the scratches, small chips, marks and stains peculiar to old things, which arrive naturally with the years. In Japanese the word is aji, literally "flavour", and it is the reason a Meiji clothing chest looks nothing like a new one.
When a piece is restored, the work begins by deciding what must be mended and what must be left alone. Mend everything and you erase what made the piece worth keeping. Every Japonista condition note is written with that distinction in mind.
What we mean by a fault
A fault, put simply, is damage that gets in the way of use. A deep scratch that exposes the bare wood beneath the finish; a structure so loose that the piece rocks or sways; a drawer that will not open. Anything that harms how the piece works or how strong it is, and so harms its value, can safely be treated as a fault.
Should you suspect a fault in a piece delivered to you, photograph it at once, together with the packaging, and write to us. The steps for in-transit damage are set out in our shipping policy, and we will guide you through what follows.
When you cannot tell which it is, ask
- Antique furniture above all may carry scratches and marks, a little warping of the timber, splits, gaps at the joints, or a trace of the smell of the house it lived in, in a way a new piece never would. We set down in the description everything we think you would want to know, and photograph the piece as closely as we can; even so, no set of photographs captures everything. Read the description to the end, and if anything in it raises a question or a doubt, ask us before you buy.
- Even recent, unused or new pieces can pick up small marks or chips in making and in storage. Small, inconspicuous marks are not always shown or described; if that would trouble you, ask first.
- For some pieces, a closer look can be arranged. Smell, or the feel of a seat, is hard to judge from pictures and words. Ask through the enquiry form for additional photographs, close-ups or a short video of the piece.
What this guide covers, and what it does not
- Marks of the kind shown below as character, within the range that does not affect use, are not treated as faults on arrival.
- Whether character or fault, we cannot accept liability for consequential loss arising from it: damage to property or person, loss of time, anticipated business profit or other financial loss.
Telling them apart: paired examples
Each pair below sets an example of character beside an example of a fault.
Scratches, chips and dents

Warping

Cracks, splits and gaps in the wood

Worm holes

Rocking and wobble

Worn finish

Fabric

Cracked or broken glass

Also treated as character
The following are also treated as character rather than as faults.






For anything not covered here, if you cannot decide whether it is character or a fault, simply ask.
Reading a tansu: the marks particular to Japanese chests
The examples above apply to old furniture of every kind. Japanese chests carry a vocabulary of their own, and these are the marks our condition notes return to most often.
| What you see | Usually character | Usually a fault |
|---|---|---|
| Iron fittings (kanagu) | Dark, even oxidation; a soft bloom of age on hand-forged iron; small losses to the edge of a decorative plate. | Active flaking rust that stains the wood; a lock that will not turn when one is described as working; a missing pull on a drawer you need to open. |
| Lacquer (urushi) | Fine crazing; the grain rising faintly through wiped lacquer; wear on corners and drawer edges where hands have rested for a century. | Lacquer lifting in flakes; patches worn through to bare wood on the face; new, glossy over-finishing presented as original. |
| Paulownia (kiri) | An even honey or grey-brown tone; soft dents in a wood that dents easily. | Water staining, mould, or drawers swollen shut. |
| Keyaki and chestnut faces | Shrinkage checks along the grain; a deepened colour under old finish. | Splits that open across a panel or run through a joint. |
| Drawers and doors | Drawers that run snugly, as Japanese drawers are made to; a slight sound of air as one closes another. | Drawers that jam, drop or have split bottoms; sliding doors that leave their tracks. |
| Carcass and joints | Small gaps at corner joints from a century of seasonal movement; old restorations, honestly done. | Loose or failed joints; sections that no longer stack true on a two-part chest. |
| Smell | The faint scent of old wood, lacquer or hearth smoke, especially in kitchen chests. | Damp, mould or strong odours that do not leave with airing. |
What a Japonista condition note tells you
Every piece we offer carries a written condition note and a grade. We describe what is there, not what we hope you will overlook: losses, replacements, restorations and later finishes are named as such. The grades themselves, and what each one promises, are set out in the Japonista grading and condition guide.
Japanese chests come to us in different states, and the listing will say which:
- Restored: cleaned, repaired and finished before it is offered.
- Restore to order: offered before restoration; you buy the piece as it stands, then agree the work, which is carried out in Japan before export, on partner-range pieces only.
- Customisable: sizes, legs, fittings or finish can be altered to your brief, at a quoted cost.
- Light repair: joints tightened, moving parts adjusted and cleaned, without refinishing.
- Sold as is: offered exactly as acquired, without cleaning or repair, at a price that reflects it.
Each state, what it includes and what it asks of you, is explained in full in Condition Grades and Restoration Options.
Answered plainly
Is a worm hole always a problem?
No. Old, clean holes in treated timber are history. Fresh powder (frass) below a hole is not: it means insects may still be active, and the piece needs treatment before it joins other furniture.
Will a restored chest look new?
It should not. Good restoration makes a chest sound and usable while keeping the colour and wear that tell its age. If you want a crisp, even surface, say so: that is a different brief, and some collectors would call it a loss.
Why is there a gap at the back of a drawer?
Solid timber moves with the seasons for as long as it exists. A drawer back or bottom that has shrunk slightly is normal; one that has split through is a fault.
Can I see more before I decide?
Yes. Ask for close-ups of any area that concerns you, of the fittings, inside the drawers, or the back and underside. Send an enquiry through the enquiry form.
How we measure Japanese furniture → The Japanese furniture glossary → Looking for a particular chest? Brief the Hunting Salon™ →Japanese furniture guides. The tansu guide · Japanese furniture glossary, A–M · Japanese furniture glossary, N–Z · Condition grades and restoration options · Character or fault · How we measure Japanese furniture · The Japonista furniture standard · Japanese interiors gallery · Before you buy · When your furniture arrives · Delivering large furniture · How we pack furniture · Customising antique furniture · Remaking old doors and fittings · Fitting old doors with confidence · Aftercare and repairs
Private concierge
Looking for something in particular?
Describe the piece or the project you have in mind. A senior advisor in Tokyo reads every case file personally and replies within two business days, with fees set out in writing before any work begins.